The Jewish Annotated New Testament and Conservative Christians

I’ve seen a few bloggers comment that they would not be buying The Jewish Annotated New Testament based on its decidedly opinionated Jewish viewpoint on issues within the New Testament.

Personally, I am very taken with the book for its massive dose of Jewish background to a collection of books written by and often for, first century Jews. It is certainly much better reference for bible study than the “gnostic” gospels, which are typically so un-Jewish as to be from a different planet than the traditional four gospels.

The book has a series of very useful tables in the back and a nice glossaryof historic and modern terms. Sidebar essays are some of my favorite features in study bibles and this one features over seventy. Some thirty longer essays in the back address the background and history with a bit more depth and in keeping with quite recent scholarship. Finally, the translation chosen is the NRSV, which remains scholars’ default version, and thus handy to have.

If you have doubts about whether you would be able to agree with the conclusions in the book, I suggest this for a test: get hold of an open copy (mine was shrink-wrapped in the store, nice but on the other hand, annoying), flip to the back, and read Amy-Jill Levine’s essay, “Bearing False Witness: Common Errors Made About Early Judaism”. She hits ten famliar ideas about Judaism in Jesus’ day and dismisses each of them. If this essay sets your teeth on edge or raises your “holy ire”, this is not the book for you. Too bad, I say, as there is much to learn in it, I think.

The book is selling quite well these days, and the Kindle edition is due on December 15, just in time for a Christmas gift for all those new Kindles. (The Fire is the poor man’s IPad, this year, it seems). Go forth and buy the book in some edition, I recommend. And if you or your special someone hasn’t gotten it yet (its six years old, and boy does that seem like yesterday)Β I recommend the Jewish Study Bible as a companion to the Jewish New Testament. It has many great essays too, and features the JPS Tanakh translation, an excellent counterpoint to Christian Old Testament translations.

Advertisements

6 responses to “The Jewish Annotated New Testament and Conservative Christians

  1. Amen there Chuck, I have my hardback copy, of course I don’t follow the pseudonymous ideas of St. Paul’s Letters especially. But overall the Jewish notes and work are worth considering! We must never loose the Jewishness of Jesus, nor the biblical and theological Judeo Covenant! (Rom. 9: 4-5, etc.) The Incarnation is forever Jewish!

      • Watch out Chuck, you may find yourself not moderated in the land of the “Law”? πŸ˜‰

        But I agree, really the real reason why Jim won’t moderate or chat with me any longer is because I called him a Northern Baptist, full-of himself, liberal! Yep I kinda did!

        Btw, I may be an eclectic and even catholic/reformed Anglican, but at heart I am a conservative one! πŸ™‚

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s